ADVANCED MANUFACTURING: Public-Private Manufacturing Clusters Can Save U.S. Munitions Supply Chain

How these investments can eliminate critical bottlenecks and revitalize the nation’s industrial base

Op-Ed by John Burer, CEO and Founder, ACMI. This was published in Advanced Manufacturing.

For decades, American defense strategy has rested on a fundamental assumption: that unmatched technological superiority, world-class force training, and two vast oceans can guarantee our national security. But a military machine is only as formidable as its capacity to sustain a fight. Today, the most significant threat to American defense isn't hiding in an adversary’s arsenal; it is the fragile, bottlenecked U.S. munitions supply chain.


Modern conflict has exposed structural vulnerabilities in our defense industrial base. The ongoing depletion of 155mm artillery shells, paired with critical shortages of key platforms like Tomahawks, ATACMS, THAAD, and Patriot interceptors, reveals a sobering truth: replenishing our stock will take years. That is time we do not have. That is an unacceptable weakness. 


This vulnerability extends deep down the supply chain, from specialized microchips to essential inputs like antimony and rare earth elements. Our industrial base can manage baseline peacetime quantities, but its capacity for long-term wartime endurance and rapid replenishment is dangerously compromised. Just one example of many is the recent revelation that the government spent $500+ million on a new facility and awarded billions in contracts to ramp up 155mm shell production, yet still fell significantly behind its targets. We cannot effectively deter or defeat an adversary if we lack the capacity to produce the weapons we need.


While supply chain disruptions affect many defense sectors, munitions present distinct challenges. Producing explosives, propellants, and warheads is inherently dangerous, heavily regulated, and constrained by niche markets. Unlike other military materiel or logistics equipment, which draw from dual-use commercial lines, munitions are heavily reliant on defense-specific specifications. High regulatory barriers present barriers to entry for new commercial companies, leaving a dwindling pool of single-source suppliers willing to absorb the significant compliance and operational costs. Furthermore, these systems rely on non-transferable tooling; you cannot simply flip a switch on a commercial assembly line to start producing missile fuselages or precision artillery fuzes.


Compounding these issues is an erratic government demand signal. Decades of "stop-and-go" procurement cycles have forced private suppliers to navigate volatile boom-and-bust funding. Faced with massive capital expenditure requirements and scarce long-term volume guarantees, smaller sub-tier vendors have systematically exited the market. What remains is a brittle supply chain stripped of redundant capacity, with fragile, single-source suppliers as single points of failure across entire complex weapons platforms.


Fixing this structural weakness requires more than just injecting additional taxpayer funding into an outdated system. It demands an operational shift toward structured Public-Private Partnerships (P3s) that bridge defense requirements with commercial manufacturing agility. Early efforts to do this with the Civil Reserve Manufacturing Network are moving in this direction, but a more purpose-built set of industrial centers will be required as well to fully address our deep industrial challenges. 


For munitions, however, the federal government must absorb market demand risk through multi-year procurement commitments for operators to support facilities development and permanent capacity increases. This policy stability provides private firms with the financial predictability needed to invest in modern, flexible infrastructure. P3 frameworks operating in this environment can streamline testing and qualification pipelines by co-funding trials and expanding private access to government testing ranges and intellectual property. Furthermore, this kind of relationship between government and the private sector incentivizes contractors to build advanced, dual-use production lines, giving the defense industrial base the dynamic flexibility needed to support commercial output during peacetime while maintaining the latent capacity to surge production during a crisis.


To reinforce these partnerships, we must also rethink geographic execution. Manufacturing efficiency relies heavily on logistics. When research hubs, component suppliers, testing facilities, and assembly plants are co-located and highly networked, operational friction decreases significantly or disappears entirely. When done properly this means tasks that once took months now take weeks, while work that took days happens in just a few hours.


Regional industrial clusters aggregate specialized suppliers, skilled technical labor, academic research centers, and freight logistics into tightly integrated ecosystems. Grouping these assets in multiple regional centers lowers lead times, enhances transparency, fosters rapid innovation, and insulates production from overseas interdiction during crisis mobilization. Crucially, these industrial clusters de-risk capital investment for private markets, allowing financial institutions to build on small amounts of initial government funding with billions in private capital.


We do not have to look far for proof that this model works. During World War II, the United States mobilized the Detroit automotive cluster to build the original "Arsenal of Democracy." At facilities like Henry Ford’s Willow Run plant, manufacturers adapted automotive assembly lines to mass-produce complex B-24 Liberator bombers, transforming bespoke aircraft manufacturing into continuous high-speed assembly. In more recent years, Toyota deployed these same efficiencies in Toyota City, combining automation with lean production to build some of the world's most reliable and profitable vehicles. 


Our strategic competitors understand this dynamic well. Chinese automaker Xiaomi leverages automation and tightly integrated domestic manufacturing clusters to produce a new vehicle every 76 seconds. While precision munitions are far more complex than commercial vehicles, the underlying manufacturing principle remains the same: speed, scale, and resilience are strengthened by co-located, networked industrial ecosystems.


P3s and clustered ecosystems offer a proven framework to revitalize our defense industrial base far beyond munitions. Private capital is available, and demand from our warfighters is clear. The government needs only to light the spark and set the goal; private enterprise is ready to do the rest.


The nature of warfare is shifting from a small number of hand-crafted expensive systems to a large number of inexpensive ones. The U.S. industrial base needs to adapt quickly. A nation that cannot resupply its military in a near-peer or peer-level conflict cannot maintain peace, guarantee economic security, or protect its interests abroad. By pairing public-private investment with modern, localized manufacturing clusters, we can eliminate critical bottlenecks, revitalize domestic industry, and ensure that America’s capacity to deter its adversaries remains unquestioned.

Next
Next

ACMI Names Winners of $3 Million Inaugural Horizon Manufacturing Cup Held at Indiana University